From Steven Carmichael


Hi Colin,
I think you drew a line under this one prematurely (scroll down to read the E-mails from readeres about Tour School entry fees and whether they should be paid by the Scottish Golf Union for the top amateurs).
It's clearly a topic that divides opinion and one that should be openly debated.
Re Franco's point about does it grow the game - of course it can. It's not the only way and some of the 'grass roots' stuff needs attention but kids can be inspired to take up the game by seeing success from a Scottish player.
There is also no real chance of kids being inspired to take up the game by a guy on a mini tour because they are not visible or high profile enough. So, by trying to help them onto the 'big show,' the SGU must be applauded.
I'm also assuming that by paying this for them there is a quid pro quo and the player would need to give something (not money but time) back when they are successful? Perhaps one of the recipients could answer this.
Now whether there should be a body that assists all young Scottish players like Chris Kelly, professional or amateur, thats a real debate......
-- Steven Carmichael

Editor: OK, Steven. Point taken. We'll keep the lines open on this topic for another day or two.